| 1912 - J. Woodard Manning |
1957 - Robert Kempenaar |
| 1913 - Harlan P. Kelsey |
1958 - Harold D. Stevenson |
| 1914 - John R. Barnes |
1959 - Harry K. Eastman |
| 1915 - C. H. Greaton |
1960 - William W. Vittner |
| 1916 - George C. Thurlow |
1961 - G. Harold Thurlow |
| 1917 - A P. Home |
1962 - Anthony Williams |
| 1918 - A. E. Robinson |
1963 - Hendrik Verkade, Jr. |
| 1919 - C. R. Burr |
1964 - Palmer W. Bigelow, Jr. |
| 1920 - Charles Adams |
1965 - V. James Vanicek, Jr. |
| 1921 - J. Farquhar |
1966 - Andrew N. Shepard |
| 1922 - Kenneth E. Gillett |
1967 - Reuben Lebeaux |
| 1923 - James A. Tufts, Jr. |
1968 - Charles S. Burr |
| 1924 - Fred Baker |
1969 - Kenneth A. Lagerquist |
| 1925 - Richard M. Wyman |
1970 - Frederick Kempenaar |
| 1926 - W. W. McCartney |
1971 - Roger G. Coggeshall |
| 1927 - P. V. Van Baarda |
1972 - Robert W. Baker |
| 1928 - Charles Adams |
1973 - Paul J. Mahoney |
| 1929 - Donald Wyman |
1974 - Robert H. Eastman |
| 1930 - Earl Holsford |
1975 - Michael D. Johnson |
| 1931 - Hugho DeWildt |
1976 - Leonard Savella |
| 1932 - Alex Cumming |
1977 - Donald J. Ward, Jr. |
| 1933 - Walton Wyman |
1978 - Robert S. Bird |
| 1934 - Clarence E. Dow |
1979 - Mario Pagliarini |
| 1935 - William N. Craig |
1980 - Richard Stevens |
| 1936 - William N. Craig |
1981 - Neil Van Sloun |
| 1937 - Joel Bames |
1982 - Kees Vandervoorn |
| 1938 - Cornelius Van Tol |
1983 - Robert Van Hof |
| 1939 - Cornelius Van Tol |
1984 - R. Wayne Mezitt |
| 1940 - Seth L. Kelsey |
1985 - Richard Gagne |
| 1941 - Louis Vanderbrook |
1986 - Robert Powell |
| 1942 - Louis Vanderbrook |
1987 - Conrad Eastman |
| 1943 - Edmund V. Mezitt |
1988 - Dixon Hoogendoorn |
| 1944 - Lloyd Hathaway |
1989 - James Stewart |
| 1945 - Lester W. Needham |
1990 - Cornelius A. Millane III |
| 1946 - Peter J. Cascio |
1991 - Dale Pierson |
| 1947 - Peter J. Cascio |
1992 - Thomas Vanicek |
| 1948 - Arthur E. Webster |
1993 - Fred Dabney |
| 1949 - Arthur E. Webster |
1994 - Frank Thomann |
| 1950 - Richard M. Wyman, Jr |
1995 - S. Jane von Trapp |
| 1951 - Luke C. May |
1996 - Jeffrey O'Donal |
| 1952 - Willard M. Bond |
1997 - William Stockman |
| 1953 - Chester E. Hogan |
1998 - Clayton Johnson |
| 1954 - John C. Brownell |
1999 - Patricia Bigelow |
| 1955 - Charles Godin |
2000 - Mark Sellew |
| 1956 - Dick Van Heiningen |
2001 - Steve Tworig |
| |
2002 - Jesse O'Brien |
| |
2003 - Jeff Huntington |
| |
2004 - Bruce Vanicek |
| |
2005 - John Bardzik |
| |
2006 - John Bardzik |
| |
2007 - Greg Schaan |
